2011 Topps

#550 Joe Mauer

A close second was #573 Nyjer Morgan and #301 Seth Smith
These are the other candidates for coolest card:

I noticed several cards where the positioning of the ball was... interesting... Reid Brignac #284 is trying to grab the ball after his bunt attempt. Josh Hamilton #650 is NOT going to catch that one! Maicer Izturis #529 is about to have a headache. The umpire has a great look at this pitch to Brennan Boesch #175. Wade Davis #467 has the best disguised move to third base, ever! Matt Cain #570 has his eye on the ball. The count on Luke Scott #294 must be 3-something :) Danny Valencia #390 is reverse-relaying the ball to left field?

Deja Vu!

John Jay #295 and 1983's Mookie Wilson Josh Willingham #225 and 2007's Jacoby Ellsbury Nick Swisher #279 and 1956's Rocky Bridges Yuniesky Betancourt #289 and 1996's Jose Offerman Magglio Ordonez #181 is the 2nd to remind me of game 2 of the '68 series (and he's a Tiger!) Carlos Beltran #515 and his "opposite number" 2007's Tad Iguchi