This is the only card that jumped (get it?) out at me... until I came to #516 Lorenzo Cain. JBJ won out based on the extension, although Cain is much dirtier!

I separated all the other contenders by "type" and the three best "also-rans" are (infield play) #42 Todd Frazier, (bunting) #592 Martin Maldonado, and (sliding) #300 Mike Trout.

I'm not sure what is going on with #449 Joe Panik (checklist) and #518 Rajai Davis.

#461 Mike Moustakas had potential, but it just looks funny. And speaking of funny, I give you #67 Hunter Pence, along with one of MLB's most athletic players, #226 Dioner Navarro. The card says 5'9" and 205lbs. and finally, I think the only topps card ever featuring a player wearing a tie... #406 Jon Lester.